Can’t Afford Your Home Anymore? Options for Bainbridge Island and Kitsap County Homeowners

Distressed couple looking at screen

Struggling to afford a mortgage on Bainbridge Island or in Kitsap County doesn’t automatically mean foreclosure or a short sale. Homeowners who are still current on payments generally have more flexibility than those already behind, and Washington’s Foreclosure Fairness Program offers free counseling and mediation access to those who qualify. The right first step depends on whether the problem is temporary, how much equity is in the property, and whether staying in the home is even the goal.

If your home has become harder to afford, the first question is not necessarily, “How quickly should I sell?” A better place to start is by asking what has actually changed and what options are still available to you.

Sometimes the problem is temporary: a job change, an unexpected expense, a period of reduced income, or another short-term disruption. Other times, the numbers have changed more permanently. The mortgage payment may be the same, but taxes, insurance, maintenance, utilities, or other household expenses have increased. The home itself may also require more money, time, or upkeep than makes sense for you now.

And in some cases, a homeowner is already behind on mortgage payments and trying to understand what happens next. Those situations require different conversations, which is why I would not begin by assuming that every homeowner struggling with affordability is headed toward foreclosure or needs to sell immediately.

If you own a home on Bainbridge Island or elsewhere in Kitsap County and are questioning whether you can continue to afford it, the best first step is to get clear about your circumstances before making a major decision.

Start by Figuring Out What Kind of Problem You Actually Have

Before deciding whether to refinance, modify your loan, rent the property, sell it, or consider another option, there are several things worth understanding first.

Is the problem temporary or likely to continue? A temporary income disruption is very different from realizing that your monthly housing costs simply no longer fit your budget. If the problem appears short-term and you want to remain in the home, that may point you toward a different set of options than a long-term affordability issue.

Are you current on your mortgage or already behind? You do not need to miss mortgage payments before considering a sale. Someone who recognizes that the home is becoming financially unsustainable may have more flexibility while payments are still current than after a foreclosure process has begun.

At the same time, being behind on payments does not automatically mean that a normal sale is impossible. The amount of equity in the property, your mortgage balance, the timing, and any other obligations attached to the home all matter.

How much equity do you have? Your mortgage balance and your home’s market value are not the same thing, and neither number by itself tells you what you would actually receive from a sale. We need to consider the likely selling price, mortgage payoff, additional liens or obligations, and anticipated selling expenses.

Finally, there is a question that often gets skipped: Do you actually want to stay in the home?

If the home still works well for your life and the financial problem appears temporary, exploring ways to keep it may make sense. If you have already been thinking about downsizing, relocating, reducing expenses, or moving to a property that requires less upkeep, the financial pressure may simply be forcing you to evaluate a decision that was already somewhere in the background.

The goal is not to steer you toward one particular answer. It is to understand the choices while you still have choices.

If You Want to Stay, Start With Your Mortgage Servicer

A real estate broker can help you understand your property’s value and what a sale might look like. I cannot tell you which mortgage-relief option is best for you, and I would not try. That conversation belongs with your mortgage servicer and, when appropriate, a qualified housing counselor, financial professional, or attorney.

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau recommends contacting your mortgage servicer if you are worried about missing a mortgage payment. Depending on the loan and the homeowner’s circumstances, possible options may include a repayment plan, forbearance, loan modification, refinancing, a short sale, or a deed in lieu of foreclosure. Not every option is available to every borrower.

One important distinction is that forbearance does not erase the payments you missed. It generally allows payments to be paused or reduced temporarily, with repayment handled later according to the terms offered by the servicer.

That is why I’m cautious about general advice that says, “Just call your lender and get a modification,” or “Just refinance.” Those may be possibilities, but they are not guarantees. What matters is what your particular servicer offers for your particular loan and circumstances.

Washington Homeowners Have a Free Resource Worth Knowing About

Washington has a useful resource for homeowners facing mortgage trouble that many people do not know about.

The Washington State Foreclosure Fairness Program provides access to foreclosure-prevention counseling, civil legal aid, and, for eligible homeowners, foreclosure mediation. Washington homeowners can also contact the Washington Homeownership Information Hotline at 1-877-894-HOME (4663) for free foreclosure-prevention counseling.

A housing counselor can help you understand the lender-side options that may be available to you. My role as a real estate broker is different. I can help you understand the real estate side of the equation: what the property is likely worth, what it might reasonably sell for, what preparation makes sense, how long a sale could take, and whether the numbers suggest that a conventional sale is realistic.

In many situations, you need both pieces of information before you can make a sensible decision.

Before You Assume You Cannot Sell, Find Out What Your Home Is Actually Worth

This is one of the areas where local real estate knowledge matters.

I would not make a decision about a Bainbridge Island or Kitsap County property based solely on an automated online valuation or on what a neighbor’s house sold for six months ago. Two houses that look similar on paper can have very different market values because of condition, location, property characteristics, waterfront or view considerations, acreage, improvements, deferred maintenance, and what buyers are responding to at that particular point in the market.

On Bainbridge Island, for example, a homeowner may have substantial equity while still finding that the monthly cost of keeping the home no longer makes financial sense. Elsewhere in Kitsap County, the pressure may involve not only the mortgage but also the cost and time required to maintain acreage, an older home, a private septic or well system, outbuildings, or a property that no longer fits the owner’s commute or lifestyle.

In other words, “I can’t afford this house anymore” does not necessarily mean “I am in foreclosure.” You may have an asset with meaningful equity that simply no longer fits your financial life, and that is a very different problem to solve.

If You Have Enough Equity, a Conventional Sale May Be the Simplest Path

If your likely sale proceeds are sufficient to pay your mortgage and the other obligations associated with the property and sale, you may be able to sell through the normal real estate process even if affordability is the reason you are moving.

You also do not have to wait until you miss a mortgage payment to explore that option. For some homeowners, selling before the situation becomes urgent provides more control over timing, preparation, pricing, and the next move.

That does not mean everyone who feels financially stretched should immediately put the house on the market. It means that if selling is one of the possibilities you are considering, it is worth understanding the numbers before dismissing it or waiting until circumstances narrow your options.

When I look at this with a homeowner, I am less interested in giving them a dramatic “your home is worth $X” number than I am in answering a more useful question: If we sold this property under realistic market conditions, what might the financial picture actually look like?

Answering that requires looking beyond the headline sales price.

What If You Owe More Than the Home Is Likely to Sell For?

If the expected proceeds from a sale will not be enough to satisfy the mortgage and other required obligations, a normal sale may not work without additional funds from the seller. Depending on the circumstances, a short sale may be one possibility.

In a short sale, the mortgage lender or servicer is asked to approve a sale in which the proceeds will be insufficient to pay the full amount owed. Lender approval is required, and the process can involve financial, legal, tax, and credit issues that extend beyond the real estate transaction itself.

The Washington State Department of Financial Institutions identifies short sales as one possible alternative that may be available to some homeowners facing foreclosure, but eligibility and lender approval depend on the individual situation.

This is also where I would bring in the appropriate professionals rather than expecting a real estate broker to answer every question. I can help evaluate and market the property, establish likely market value, work through the real estate transaction, and communicate with the parties involved in the sale. Questions about tax consequences, bankruptcy, deficiency liability, credit effects, or legal rights belong with the appropriate attorney, tax professional, financial professional, housing counselor, or lender.

What About Renting the Home Instead?

Renting the property is sometimes suggested as if it automatically solves an affordability problem. It can be a good option in the right circumstances, but the numbers are worth running before making that assumption.

The question is not simply whether the monthly rent is close to the mortgage payment. You also need to consider property taxes, insurance, repairs, maintenance, vacancy, property management if you will not manage it yourself, and the possibility of larger expenses while you continue to own the property.

You should also talk with the appropriate insurance, tax, lending, and legal professionals about issues that may arise when converting an owner-occupied home into a rental.

A property that produces adequate cash flow and fits your long-term plans may be worth holding. A property that loses money every month while adding the responsibilities of being a landlord may simply replace one financial problem with another.

If You Are Already Behind on Your Mortgage, Do Not Assume It Is Too Late to Sell

This is another area where the simple “foreclosure versus short sale” framing can create unnecessary panic.

Being behind on mortgage payments does not, by itself, tell us whether you have equity or whether a conventional sale is still possible. A homeowner could be several payments behind and still own a property with substantial equity. Another homeowner could be completely current on payments but owe close to what the property is worth.

If you are behind, I would want to understand approximately what you owe, how many payments have been missed, whether you have received formal notices from your lender or trustee, whether there are other mortgages, liens, judgments, unpaid property taxes, or obligations attached to the property, and what the home is realistically worth in the current market.

Timing matters too. If you have received a Notice of Default, Notice of Trustee Sale, or other legal documents related to foreclosure, Washington’s Foreclosure Fairness Program has specific procedures and eligibility requirements for mediation. Homeowners cannot refer themselves directly into the mediation program; a housing counselor or attorney makes the referral for eligible homeowners.

At that point, involving a qualified housing counselor or attorney promptly becomes especially important while we evaluate the real estate options.

What I Can Help You Understand as a Real Estate Broker

If you call me because your home is becoming difficult to afford, I am not going to begin by telling you to list it. I want to understand the problem first, then determine what information would actually help you make a decision.

One of the first things I can do is help establish what the property is realistically worth in today’s market. That means looking beyond an automated estimate or the highest nearby sale and considering the specific property, current competition, buyer demand, condition, and marketability.

From there, we can estimate what a sale might actually net after anticipated selling expenses, the mortgage payoff, and other known obligations. That is often much more useful than focusing on a single sales-price number.

We can also talk about preparation. When cash is already tight, spending heavily on improvements before selling may make no sense. In some cases, doing less is the smarter strategy. I can help distinguish between work that is likely to matter to buyers and projects that probably will not justify their cost.

Timing is another part of the conversation. How quickly a property could reasonably be prepared and brought to market depends on the home, its condition, the market, and whether outside lender approval is required.

Once we understand the likely value, payoff information, preparation needs, and timing, we are in a much better position to determine whether a conventional sale appears possible or whether the situation requires additional information from the lender, title company, attorney, housing counselor, or another professional.

That is the point of the initial conversation: getting enough clarity to choose a sensible strategy.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I wait until I miss a mortgage payment before considering selling?

No. If you already know that the home’s long-term cost no longer works for you, you can explore selling while you are still current on the mortgage. Understanding your home’s value and likely net proceeds does not obligate you to sell; it simply gives you better information.

Can I sell my home if I am behind on payments?

Potentially, yes. The important questions are how much you owe, what the property is likely to sell for, whether there are additional liens or obligations, and where you are in the lender’s collection or foreclosure process. Being behind does not automatically mean that a short sale is required.

What if my home is worth less than I owe?

A short sale may be one possible path if the lender agrees to accept less than the full amount owed, but lender approval is required. Because a short sale can involve legal, tax, financial, and credit issues, it is important to get advice from the appropriate professionals in addition to working with a real estate broker experienced with these transactions.

Will selling my home hurt my credit?

A normal real estate sale is not the same thing as missing mortgage payments, completing a short sale, entering foreclosure, or using another form of loss mitigation. Credit consequences depend on your circumstances and should be discussed with your lender, housing counselor, or another qualified financial or credit professional rather than assumed from general advice online.

Is renting my home better than selling it?

Sometimes, but not automatically. The useful comparison is the property’s realistic rental income against all of the costs and responsibilities of continuing to own it. If renting is being considered mainly because selling feels difficult, those numbers deserve a careful look first.

Who should I call first if I am worried I cannot afford my home?

If you are concerned about making your mortgage payment, contacting your mortgage servicer and a qualified housing counselor is an important first step. If you also want to understand what selling would look like, a real estate broker can help establish realistic market value, likely sale proceeds, preparation needs, and timing.

If foreclosure proceedings, bankruptcy, legal documents, tax questions, or other legal issues are involved, you should also speak with an appropriately qualified attorney or other professional.

You Do Not Have to Decide Everything in One Conversation

Homeowners sometimes avoid asking a real estate broker questions because they assume the conversation will immediately turn into a listing appointment. It does not have to.

If you own a home on Bainbridge Island or elsewhere in Kitsap County and the financial side of homeownership is becoming uncomfortable, I am happy to help you understand the real estate part of the equation. We can look at the property’s likely value, what selling might realistically involve, and whether a conventional sale appears to make sense. If the situation requires lender, legal, financial, or tax expertise beyond my role, I will tell you that too.

The goal is to make sure you understand your options well enough to make a good decision.

Let’s talk about your real estate plans.

Book a conversation with Lori Sinclair

Phone: (206) 347-0427 Email: [email protected]


About Lori Sinclair, Managing Broker, REALTOR®

Lori Sinclair is a Managing Broker with Realogics Sotheby’s International Realty and holds the Short Sales and Foreclosure Resource (SFR®) certification, serving buyers, sellers, and property owners throughout Bainbridge Island and Kitsap County, Washington. Licensed in real estate since 1998, Lori brings nearly three decades of real estate experience to residential sales, pricing strategy, property marketing, negotiation, relocation, luxury and waterfront properties, estate and probate-related properties, and complex transactions. She has served Bainbridge Island and Kitsap County for more than six years.

Earlier in her career, Lori built a successful real estate business in Houston, where she ranked among the top 1% of REALTORS® in the market. She later stepped away from real estate sales to build a multimillion-dollar automation company with her husband. After successfully selling that company to an international engineering firm in 2019, Lori moved to Washington and returned to real estate.

For homeowners navigating distressed or financially complicated property situations, Lori’s professional credentials also include the Pricing Strategy Advisor (PSA) designation.

Lori currently serves as Treasurer of Washington REALTORS® and State Liaison for Women’s Council of REALTORS® Washington. She is a Past President of the Kitsap County Association of REALTORS® and was named its 2024 REALTOR® of the Year. In 2023, she was voted Best Real Estate Agent in the Best of Bainbridge competition.

Move Smart. Move Forward.

Realogics Sotheby’s International Realty Equal Housing Opportunity

This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal, tax, financial, bankruptcy, credit, or foreclosure advice. Mortgage-relief programs, lender requirements, foreclosure procedures, tax consequences, credit effects, and individual circumstances vary. Homeowners should consult their mortgage servicer and appropriately qualified housing, legal, tax, and financial professionals regarding their particular situation.

Share:
Send Us
A Message

    Skip to content